Top-Rated Pantry Delivery in Hicksville, NY


Condiments, Dips, and Salsas

Mike's Picks
Edamame Dip

Edamame Dip

MOMO dressing

Classic Hummus

Classic Hummus

Ithaca Cold-Crafted

Lemon Beet Hummus

Lemon Beet Hummus

Ithaca Cold-Crafted

Lemon and Garlic Hummus

Lemon and Garlic Hummus

Ithaca Cold-Crafted

Lemon and Dill Hummus

Lemon and Dill Hummus

Ithaca Cold-Crafted

Roasted Red Pepper Hummus

Roasted Red Pepper Hummus

Ithaca Cold-Crafted

New
Kalamata Olive Hummus

Kalamata Olive Hummus

Ithaca Cold-Crafted

Smoked Chipotle Hummus

Smoked Chipotle Hummus

Ithaca Cold-Crafted

Organic Tahini

Organic Tahini

Seed + Mill

Mike's Picks
Thai Hot Sauce

Thai Hot Sauce

SD Sauce

Mike's Picks
Vegan Thai Hot Sauce

Vegan Thai Hot Sauce

SD Sauce

Organic Sriracha Chili Sauce

Organic Sriracha Chili Sauce

Kitchen Garden Farm

Out of stock
Cherry Bomb Hot Sauce

Cherry Bomb Hot Sauce

Beth's Farm Kitchen

Red Pepper Romesco

Red Pepper Romesco

Haven's Kitchen

Nutty Lemongrass Sauce

Nutty Lemongrass Sauce

Haven's Kitchen

Zippy Chili Harissa

Zippy Chili Harissa

Haven's Kitchen

Salsa Roja

Salsa Roja

Tortilleria Nixtamal

Salsa Verde

Salsa Verde

Tortilleria Nixtamal

Roasted Chili Salsa

Roasted Chili Salsa

Kitchen Garden Farm

Mike's Picks
Tomato 'nduja

Tomato 'nduja

City Saucery

Sun Dried Tomato Tapenade

Sun Dried Tomato Tapenade

Organic Olive Juice Company

Sun Dried Vegetable Tapenade

Sun Dried Vegetable Tapenade

Organic Olive Juice Company

Hot Chili Sambal

Hot Chili Sambal

Auria's Malaysian Kitchen

Mike's Picks
Lime Leaf Sambal

Lime Leaf Sambal

Auria's Malaysian Kitchen

Salted Caramel Kaya

Salted Caramel Kaya

Auria's Malaysian Kitchen

Pandan Coconut Kaya

Pandan Coconut Kaya

Auria's Malaysian Kitchen

40°N Fish Sauce

40°N Fish Sauce

Red Boat

Habanero Hot Sauce

Habanero Hot Sauce

Beth's Farm Kitchen

Out of stock
Eggplant Caponata

Eggplant Caponata

Divine Brine

New
Out of stock
Basil Pine Nut Pesto

Basil Pine Nut Pesto

East End Food Institute

New
Low in stock
Kale Pistachio Pesto

Kale Pistachio Pesto

East End Food Institute

Mike's Picks
Tzatziki Sauce

Tzatziki Sauce

East End Food Institute

New
Vegan Spinach Walnut Pesto

Vegan Spinach Walnut Pesto

East End Food Institute

New
Golden Turmeric Tahini

Golden Turmeric Tahini

Haven's Kitchen

Low in stock
Moutard Basque

Moutard Basque

Les Trois Petits Cochons

Whole Grain Mustard (A L'Ancienne)

Whole Grain Mustard (A L'Ancienne)

Les Trois Petits Cochons

New
Original Fermented Kimchi Sauce

Original Fermented Kimchi Sauce

forward ROOTS

New
Vegan Fermented Kimchi Sauce

Vegan Fermented Kimchi Sauce

forward ROOTS

Chips, Crackers, and Snacks

Plain Potato Chips - 6oz Bag

Plain Potato Chips - 6oz Bag

North Fork Potato Chips

Salt & Vinegar Potato Chips - 6 oz Bag

Salt & Vinegar Potato Chips - 6 oz Bag

North Fork Potato Chips

Barbeque Potato Chips - 6 oz Bag

Barbeque Potato Chips - 6 oz Bag

North Fork Potato Chips

Tortilla Chips

Tortilla Chips

Tortilleria Nixtamal

Out of stock
Handmade Hard Pretzels

Handmade Hard Pretzels

Martin's Pretzels

Garlic & Rosemary Potato Chips - 6 oz Bag

Garlic & Rosemary Potato Chips - 6 oz Bag

North Fork Potato Chips

Dressings, Marinades, and Oils

New
Beet Vinaigrette

Beet Vinaigrette

East End Food Institute

New
Cilantro Lime Dressing

Cilantro Lime Dressing

East End Food Institute

New
Garlic & Herb Vinaigrette

Garlic & Herb Vinaigrette

East End Food Institute

New
Mediterranean Vinaigrette

Mediterranean Vinaigrette

East End Food Institute

Image
coming
soon
New
Apple Cider Vinegar

Apple Cider Vinegar

Keepwell Vinegar

New
Classic Soy Sauce

Classic Soy Sauce

Keepwell Vinegar

Concord Grape Vinegar

Concord Grape Vinegar

Keepwell Vinegar

New
Malt Vinegar

Malt Vinegar

Keepwell Vinegar

Image
coming
soon
New
Rice Vinegar

Rice Vinegar

Keepwell Vinegar

Turmeric Vinegar

Turmeric Vinegar

Keepwell Vinegar

Arbequina Extra Virgin Olive Oil - 500ml

Arbequina Extra Virgin Olive Oil - 500ml

O-Med

Organic Sunflower Seed Oil

Organic Sunflower Seed Oil

Stony Brook

Thai Yellow Curry Sauce

Thai Yellow Curry Sauce

Watcharee's

Arbequina Extra Virgin Olive Oil - 1L

Arbequina Extra Virgin Olive Oil - 1L

O-Med

Chardonnay Vinegar

Chardonnay Vinegar

O-Med

Cabernet Sauvignon Vinegar

Cabernet Sauvignon Vinegar

O-Med

Mike's Picks
Pedro Ximenez Vinegar

Pedro Ximenez Vinegar

O-Med

Sherry Vinegar

Sherry Vinegar

O-Med

Rosé Vinegar

Rosé Vinegar

O-Med

Basil Caesar Dressing

Basil Caesar Dressing

Gotham Greens

Green Goddess Dressing

Green Goddess Dressing

Gotham Greens

Vegan Goddess Dressing

Vegan Goddess Dressing

Gotham Greens

Vegan Lemon Basil Vinaigrette

Vegan Lemon Basil Vinaigrette

Gotham Greens

Mike's Picks
Caramelized Onion Dressing

Caramelized Onion Dressing

MOMO dressing

Basil Dressing

Basil Dressing

MOMO dressing

Ginger Dressing

Ginger Dressing

MOMO dressing

Non Oil Shiso Dressing

Non Oil Shiso Dressing

MOMO dressing

Sesame Dressing

Sesame Dressing

MOMO dressing

Mike's Picks
Yuzu Jalapeno Dressing

Yuzu Jalapeno Dressing

MOMO dressing

Out of stock
Apple Miso Marinade

Apple Miso Marinade

MOMO dressing

Nut Butters, Jams, and Preserves

Banana Jam

Banana Jam

BRINS Jam & Marmalade

Rosemary Grapefruit

Rosemary Grapefruit

BRINS Jam & Marmalade

Strawberry Lemongrass

Strawberry Lemongrass

BRINS Jam & Marmalade

Peach Jam

Peach Jam

Beth's Farm Kitchen

Cherry Chai Jam

Cherry Chai Jam

BRINS Jam & Marmalade

Chili Pepper Jam

Chili Pepper Jam

BRINS Jam & Marmalade

Lemon Saffron Jam

Lemon Saffron Jam

BRINS Jam & Marmalade

Mike's Picks
Strawberry Rhubarb Jam

Strawberry Rhubarb Jam

Beth's Farm Kitchen

Sweet Blackberry Jam

Sweet Blackberry Jam

Beth's Farm Kitchen

Red Raspberry Jam

Red Raspberry Jam

Beth's Farm Kitchen

Grape Jam

Grape Jam

Beth's Farm Kitchen

Out of stock
Triple Fruit Marmalade

Triple Fruit Marmalade

Beth's Farm Kitchen

Out of stock
Plain Jane Creamy Peanut Butter

Plain Jane Creamy Peanut Butter

Saratoga Peanut Butter Company

Out of stock
Plain Jane Chunky Peanut Butter

Plain Jane Chunky Peanut Butter

Saratoga Peanut Butter Company

Out of stock
Plain Jane Organic Peanut Butter

Plain Jane Organic Peanut Butter

Saratoga Peanut Butter Company

Chillin' Chocolate Peanut Butter

Chillin' Chocolate Peanut Butter

Saratoga Peanut Butter Company

Low in stock
Coconut Cashew Butter

Coconut Cashew Butter

Laurel's Butter

The Selfie Almond Butter

The Selfie Almond Butter

Laurel's Butter

Morning Joe Spread

Morning Joe Spread

Karmalize Me

Spicy Thai Almond Butter

Spicy Thai Almond Butter

Karmalize Me

Low in stock
Organic Sunflower Seed Butter

Organic Sunflower Seed Butter

Karmalize Me

Granola, Dried Fruit, and Nuts

New
Out of stock
Everything Bagel Granola

Everything Bagel Granola

Byrdfood

New
Low in stock
Smokey Chipotle Granola

Smokey Chipotle Granola

Byrdfood

Maple Pepitas (Roasted Pumpkin Seeds)

Maple Pepitas (Roasted Pumpkin Seeds)

Stony Brook

Sweet Chili Butternut Pepitas

Sweet Chili Butternut Pepitas

Stony Brook

Pasta and Sauce

"Ugly" Tomato Sauce

"Ugly" Tomato Sauce

City Saucery

Spicy "Ugly" Tomato Sauce

Spicy "Ugly" Tomato Sauce

City Saucery

Classic Spicy Sauce

Classic Spicy Sauce

Jar Goods

Fresh Plain Fettuccine

Fresh Plain Fettuccine

Knoll Krest Farm

Fresh Whole Wheat Fettuccine

Fresh Whole Wheat Fettuccine

Knoll Krest Farm

Flours, Grains, and Beans

Image
coming
soon
Black Coco Beans

Black Coco Beans

Baer's Best Beans

Image
coming
soon
Marfax Beans

Marfax Beans

Baer's Best Beans

Image
coming
soon
Organic Great Northern Beans

Organic Great Northern Beans

Baer's Best Beans

Image
coming
soon
Vermont Cranberry Beans

Vermont Cranberry Beans

Baer's Best Beans

Image
coming
soon
Yellow Eye Beans

Yellow Eye Beans

Baer's Best Beans

Organic Mung Beans

Organic Mung Beans

Karmalize Me

Low in stock
Organic Cracked Oats

Organic Cracked Oats

Maine Grains

New
Out of stock
Organic Brown Rice

Organic Brown Rice

Massa Organics

New
Out of stock
Dried Marcella Beans

Dried Marcella Beans

Rancho Gordo

All-Purpose Flour

All-Purpose Flour

Wild Hive Farm

Organically Grown Dried Black Turtle Beans

Organically Grown Dried Black Turtle Beans

Wild Hive Farm

Organically Grown Dried Pinto Beans

Organically Grown Dried Pinto Beans

Wild Hive Farm

Organically Grown Dried Red Kidney Beans

Organically Grown Dried Red Kidney Beans

Wild Hive Farm

Honey, Syrups, and Sweeteners

Local Blueberry Honey

Local Blueberry Honey

Andrew's Local Honey

Local Hot Honey

Local Hot Honey

Andrew's Local Honey

Local Matcha Honey

Local Matcha Honey

Andrew's Local Honey

Local Raw Honey

Local Raw Honey

Andrew's Local Honey

Local Sea Salt Honey

Local Sea Salt Honey

Andrew's Local Honey

Local Vanilla Honey

Local Vanilla Honey

Andrew's Local Honey

Mike's Picks
Local Whipped Honey

Local Whipped Honey

Andrew's Local Honey

Raw Honey Comb (Large)

Raw Honey Comb (Large)

Andrew's Local Honey

Raw Honey Comb (Small)

Raw Honey Comb (Small)

Andrew's Local Honey

Low in stock
Maple Sugar

Maple Sugar

Deep Mountain Maple

Pure Maple Syrup - Amber

Pure Maple Syrup - Amber

Deep Mountain Maple

Pure Maple Syrup - Traditional Dark

Pure Maple Syrup - Traditional Dark

Deep Mountain Maple

New
Organic Light Corn Syrup

Organic Light Corn Syrup

Wholesome Sweeteners

New
Organic Molasses

Organic Molasses

Wholesome Sweeteners

Pickles & Olives

Organic Piparra Peppers

Organic Piparra Peppers

Aintzia Farms

Out of stock
Heavenly Halves Dill Pickles

Heavenly Halves Dill Pickles

Divine Brine

Cornichons

Cornichons

Les Trois Petits Cochons

Aloreña Olives (Pitted)

Aloreña Olives (Pitted)

Losada

Carmona Olive Mix

Carmona Olive Mix

Losada

Cornicabra Olives

Cornicabra Olives

Losada

Natural Olive Mix (Pitted)

Natural Olive Mix (Pitted)

Losada

Dried Herbs, Spices, and Blends

New
Ground Allspice Berries

Ground Allspice Berries

Burlap & Barrel

New
King Caraway

King Caraway

Burlap & Barrel

New
Purple Stripe Garlic

Purple Stripe Garlic

Burlap & Barrel

Sweet Pepper Paprika

Sweet Pepper Paprika

Burlap & Barrel

Mike's Picks
Out of stock
Royal Cinnamon

Royal Cinnamon

Burlap & Barrel

Low in stock
Zanzibar Peppercorns

Zanzibar Peppercorns

Burlap & Barrel

Black Urfa Chili

Black Urfa Chili

Burlap & Barrel

Blue Poppy Flower Seeds

Blue Poppy Flower Seeds

Burlap & Barrel

New
Low in stock
Buffalo Ginger

Buffalo Ginger

Burlap & Barrel

Flowering Hyssop Thyme

Flowering Hyssop Thyme

Burlap & Barrel

New
Morogoro Cacao Powder

Morogoro Cacao Powder

Burlap & Barrel

Pemba Cloves

Pemba Cloves

Burlap & Barrel

Silk Chili

Silk Chili

Burlap & Barrel

New
True Star Anise

True Star Anise

Burlap & Barrel

Wild Icelandic Kelp

Wild Icelandic Kelp

Burlap & Barrel

Low in stock
Desert Hibiscus

Desert Hibiscus

Burlap & Barrel

Dried Chanterelle Mushrooms

Dried Chanterelle Mushrooms

North Spore

Dried Lobster Mushrooms

Dried Lobster Mushrooms

North Spore

Dried Morel Mushrooms

Dried Morel Mushrooms

North Spore

Dried Porcini Mushrooms

Dried Porcini Mushrooms

North Spore

CBD

Toast CBD Oil - Cinnamon (500mg)

Toast CBD Oil - Cinnamon (500mg)

Toast

Toast CBD Oil - Cold Pressed Orange (500mg)

Toast CBD Oil - Cold Pressed Orange (500mg)

Toast

Toast CBD Oil - Original (250mg)

Toast CBD Oil - Original (250mg)

Toast

Low in stock
Toast CBD Oil - Original (500mg)

Toast CBD Oil - Original (500mg)

Toast


Shop by Department